Top 24 Individual Health Insurance Companies in Pennsylvania
Top 24 Individual Health Insurance Companies in Pennsylvania
Pennsylvania's individual health insurance industry caters to a broad array of consumers looking for personalized coverage. It includes corporations, independent brokers, and family-run agencies that offer tailored plans such as Medicare, Medicaid, and supplemental healthcare. With an ongoing shift towards digital solutions and consumer-centric models, this industry is evolving. Insurers are embracing technology to enhance customer experience and simplify plan enrollment. As health regulations adapt, companies are focusing on broader reach, supporting underserved populations while managing the complexities of health insurance legislation. These trends reflect a dynamic future aimed at improving accessibility and affordability.
The companies in this listing range in size from small family-owned agencies to larger corporate entities. Most are headquartered in Pennsylvania's major cities, such as Philadelphia and Harrisburg, and span back decades, with founding years primarily in the 20th century. A mix of specialization defines this industry, with many companies focusing on Medicare, individual health coverage, and supplemental insurance plans. Their rich histories and ongoing insights into health insurance trends make these companies key players in the market.
Continue reading to discover the top individual health insurance companies in Pennsylvania.
Top 24 Individual Health Insurance Companies in Pennsylvania
1. AmeriHealth Administrators
- Website: amerihealth.com
- Ownership type: Corporate
- Headquarters: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
- Latest funding: January 2004
- Founded year: 1988
- Headcount: 501-1000
- LinkedIn: amerihealth-administrators
AmeriHealth Administrators, based in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, has been operational since 1988. The company specializes in health insurance, offering a variety of plans and services designed for individuals, families, and employers. Their offerings include Medicare options and wellness programs, reflecting a commitment to accessible and affordable health coverage. AmeriHealth serves a broad customer base, including consumers seeking personal health insurance and businesses looking for employee health benefits. The company also provides third-party administration services, which allows them to manage self-funded health plans and cater to unique populations. AmeriHealth's focus on community health and well-being is evident in their programs aimed at preventive care and support for mental health, making them a significant player in the health insurance industry.
2. Highmark Blueshield
- Website: highmarkblueshield.com
- Ownership type: Private
- Headquarters: Allentown, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Founded year: 1930
- Headcount: 11-50
- LinkedIn: highmark-blueshield
Highmark Blueshield, based in Allentown, Pennsylvania, is a private health insurance provider that has been serving consumers since its founding in 1930. The company offers a range of health plans tailored to individual and family needs, including options under the Affordable Care Act (ACA). Highmark also provides Medicare, Medicaid, and Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP) plans, demonstrating its commitment to accessible healthcare for various demographics. The company places a strong emphasis on mental health support, offering resources for conditions such as depression and anxiety. Highmark's focus on community health initiatives and corporate responsibility reflects its dedication to improving the well-being of the populations it serves. With a relatively small team of 11-50 employees, Highmark operates with a personalized approach, aiming to help members navigate their health insurance options effectively.
3. Jefferson Health Plans
- Website: jeffersonhealthplans.com
- Ownership type: Private
- Headquarters: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
- Founded year: 1984
- Headcount: 501-1000
- LinkedIn: jefferson-health-plans
Jefferson Health Plans, based in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, is a private health insurance provider that has been serving individuals and families since its inception in 1984. The company specializes in offering a range of insurance products, including Medicare Advantage Plans and Individual & Family Plans. Jefferson Health Plans aims to provide affordable healthcare coverage, ensuring that members have access to necessary medical services while managing healthcare costs effectively. They are particularly noted for their low-priced Silver plans and options with $0 medical deductibles, which appeal to cost-conscious consumers. The company operates entirely within the United States and has a workforce of approximately 1,214 employees. Jefferson Health Plans is marketed under the umbrella of Health Partners Plans, Inc., which allows them to offer additional products such as Medicaid and CHIP plans, further enhancing their service offerings in the health insurance market.
4. Youngs Insurance Services, INC
- Website: yisonline.com
- Ownership type: Family Owned
- Headquarters: Collegeville, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
- Founded year: 1997
- Headcount: 11-50
- LinkedIn: youngs-insurance-services-inc
Youngs Insurance Services, INC, founded in 1997 and based in Collegeville, Pennsylvania, operates as a family-owned insurance brokerage. The company specializes in health and life insurance products, offering a range of services that include Medicare plans, individual and family health insurance, and dental insurance. They cater to both consumers and small businesses, providing tailored assistance to help clients understand and select the best insurance options for their needs. Youngs Insurance Services prides itself on its personal approach, ensuring that clients have a dedicated agent to guide them through the complexities of insurance. The firm has built a reputation for quality customer service, maintaining close relationships with clients and offering annual reviews of their coverage. This ongoing engagement reflects their commitment to adapting to changes in the insurance market and ensuring that clients receive the most suitable options available.
5. Main Line Benefits
- Website: mlbenefitsco.com
- Ownership type: Private
- Headquarters: Malvern, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
- Founded year: 2021
- Headcount: 1-10
- LinkedIn: financial-protections-services-corp
Main Line Benefits, based in Malvern, Pennsylvania, is an insurance agency that specializes in providing a variety of insurance services tailored to the needs of individuals, families, and small businesses. Founded in 2021, the company has quickly positioned itself as a resource for clients seeking assistance with health insurance, Medicare plans, supplemental coverage, and life insurance. They pride themselves on their personalized approach, helping clients navigate the complexities of the insurance market by offering customized options that align with their needs and budgets. Main Line Benefits collaborates with over 180 providers to ensure clients have access to a wide range of plans. Their focus on customer service is reflected in their high satisfaction ratings, with numerous positive testimonials highlighting their knowledgeable agents and supportive service. The company operates without any reported funding, indicating a self-sustained growth model as they build their client base and expand their market presence.
6. Fringe Benefit ServicesPA
- Website: fringebenefitservices.com
- Ownership type: Family Owned
- Headquarters: Sharon, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Founded year: 1970
- Headcount: 11-50
- LinkedIn: fringe-benefit-servicespa
Fringe Benefit ServicesPA, based in Sharon, Pennsylvania, is a family-owned insurance agency that has been serving clients since 1970. Originally known as Wallace & Associates, the company has built a reputation for providing a wide range of insurance products, including health, life, and disability insurance. They cater to both individual consumers and businesses, emphasizing personalized consultations to help clients navigate their insurance options. With partnerships with over 60 well-known insurance carriers, Fringe Benefit ServicesPA offers a variety of plans tailored to meet the unique needs of their clients. Their commitment to service and personal attention has allowed them to maintain a strong presence in the local market, particularly in Pennsylvania and Northeastern Ohio. The agency also provides resources for Medicare planning, showcasing their expertise in this area. Despite not having reported any funding, their long-standing history and focus on customer care position them as a relevant player in the insurance industry.
7. Custom Benefit Plans Inc.
- Website: custombenefitplans.com
- Ownership type: Private
- Headquarters: Willow Grove, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
- Founded year: 1998
- Headcount: 11-50
- LinkedIn: custom-benefit-plans-inc
Custom Benefit Plans Inc. is an insurance agency based in Willow Grove, Pennsylvania, that has been operational since 1998. The company specializes in health insurance, life insurance, and annuities, catering to individuals, families, and businesses. With a team of experienced professionals, Custom Benefit Plans provides personalized guidance to clients, helping them navigate the complexities of insurance options. They focus on understanding clients' unique needs and offer tailored solutions to manage risk and ensure adequate coverage. The agency represents all major insurance carriers, which allows them to provide a broad spectrum of products and services. Their commitment to customer service is evident in their approach to assisting clients with enrollment in Medicare plans and individual health insurance, ensuring that clients receive the best possible coverage for their circumstances. Custom Benefit Plans also supports independent agents and affiliated agencies, providing them with resources and training to enhance their service offerings.
8. NTI Group
- Website: ntigroup.net
- Ownership type: Corporate
- Headquarters: Lancaster, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 50%, Australia 35%, Denmark 15%
- Latest funding: $182.0M, January 2008
- Founded year: 2002
- Headcount: 11-50
- LinkedIn: nti-group
NTI Group, founded in 2002 and based in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, is an insurance agency that specializes in a range of insurance solutions, prominently including health insurance. The company serves local employers, individuals, and families, helping them secure adequate protection and navigate the often complex world of insurance options. NTI Group prides itself on delivering quality customer service and creating tailored insurance packages that meet the specific needs of its clients. Their offerings extend beyond health insurance to include workers' compensation, employee benefits, and life insurance, showcasing their comprehensive approach to insurance solutions. With a team of experienced agents and financial consultants, NTI Group aims to provide cost-effective coverage options that align with the unique requirements of their customers. The company has a notable presence in the insurance market, particularly in the areas it serves, and is committed to helping clients understand and maximize their insurance benefits.
9. Gallen Insurance
- Website: galleninsurance.com
- Ownership type: Corporate
- Headquarters: Shillington, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
- Latest funding: August 2023
- Founded year: 1957
- Headcount: 11-50
- LinkedIn: gallen-insurance
Gallen Insurance, based in Shillington, Pennsylvania, has been serving the insurance needs of individuals and businesses since its founding in 1957. With a team of 22 employees, the agency specializes in a range of insurance solutions, including personal insurance, business insurance, and employee benefits. Their offerings include Medicare, individual health insurance, auto insurance, and life insurance, catering to both individual consumers and businesses. Gallen Insurance prides itself on being an independent agency, which allows them to provide clients with multiple coverage options tailored to their specific needs. The agency has received recognition in the local community, including awards such as the Berks County People’s Choice Award, highlighting their commitment to customer service and community engagement. Gallen Insurance continues to adapt to the evolving insurance landscape, ensuring that they meet the needs of their clients effectively.
10. URL Insurance Group
- Website: urlinsgroup.com
- Ownership type: Family Owned
- Headquarters: Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
- Founded year: 1986
- Headcount: 11-50
- LinkedIn: url-insurance-group
URL Insurance Group, based in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, is a family-owned insurance brokerage that has been serving clients since 1986. The company provides a wide array of insurance products, including health, life, and Medicare insurance. With a dedicated team of nearly 50 employees, URL Insurance Group focuses on delivering personalized service to individuals, families, and businesses. They assist clients in navigating the complexities of insurance, ensuring that they find the best solutions for their needs. URL Insurance Group partners with over 100 top carriers, allowing them to offer a variety of health insurance options, including individual and family health plans, Medicare Advantage Plans, and supplemental insurance. Their commitment to client satisfaction and their extensive experience in the industry position them as a relevant player in the individual health insurance sector.
11. HTA Insurance Services
- Website: hta-insurance.com
- Ownership type: Private
- Headquarters: Exton, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
- Founded year: 1976
- Headcount: 11-50
- LinkedIn: hta-insurance-services
HTA Insurance Services, founded in 1976 and based in Exton, Pennsylvania, is a private insurance agency that specializes in Medicare and Property & Casualty Insurance. With a dedicated team of approximately 29 employees, HTA has built a reputation for providing personalized consultation and enrollment assistance to both individuals and businesses. The company aims to simplify the often complex world of insurance, focusing on education and support to help clients make informed decisions. HTA has been particularly active in the Medicare market since 1998, adapting to changes in the health insurance landscape and positioning itself as a trusted partner for clients. Their commitment to client service is reflected in their approach, where advisors are salaried and not incentivized by commissions, ensuring that the focus remains on the best interests of the clients. HTA represents over 20 insurance carriers, allowing them to offer a range of options tailored to individual needs. The company has also expanded its offerings to include Property & Casualty Insurance, further enhancing its service portfolio. HTA's leadership, under CEO Tracy Keesey, emphasizes a client-first philosophy, aiming to be a lifelong partner for their clients in navigating insurance decisions.
12. Robert J. Stillwell Agency
- Website: robertjstillwell.com
- Ownership type: Family Owned
- Headquarters: Spring House, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
- Founded year: 1968
- Headcount: 11-50
- LinkedIn: robert-j-stillwell-agency
The Robert J. Stillwell Agency, established in 1968, is a family-owned insurance agency based in Spring House, Pennsylvania. With a dedicated team of 23 employees, the agency has built a reputation for providing personalized insurance services to individuals and families. They specialize in a variety of insurance products, including health insurance, life insurance, and Medicare plans. The agency prides itself on its commitment to customer service, ensuring that clients receive tailored solutions that meet their unique needs. Their independent status allows them to work with multiple insurance carriers, providing clients with a range of options. The agency's proactive approach includes annual policy reviews to adapt to changing client needs, reinforcing their focus on individual attention and support in navigating the insurance landscape.
13. BGA Insurance Group
- Website: bgainsurance.net
- Ownership type: Private
- Headquarters: West Conshohocken, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
- Founded year: 2008
- Headcount: 11-50
- LinkedIn: bga-insurance-group
BGA Insurance Group, founded in 2008 and based in West Conshohocken, Pennsylvania, is a private insurance agency that specializes in Medicare and retirement planning services. With a team of approximately 36 employees, the company provides tailored support to seniors and their families, helping them navigate the complexities of healthcare options. Their services include Medicare Supplement Insurance, Medicare Advantage plans, and life insurance, among others. BGA Insurance Group prides itself on offering personalized consultations, often meeting clients in their homes or local settings to ensure a comfortable and informative experience. The agency is dedicated to keeping clients informed about changes in Medicare and other relevant insurance matters, which enhances their role as a trusted advisor in the health insurance space.
14. Neishloss & Fleming, LLC
- Website: neishloss.com
- Ownership type: Corporate
- Headquarters: Canonsburg, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
- Latest funding: January 2018
- Founded year: 1982
- Headcount: 11-50
- LinkedIn: neishloss-%26-fleming-inc.
Neishloss & Fleming, LLC, founded in 1982 and based in Canonsburg, Pennsylvania, is an insurance agency that specializes in Medicare and health-related products. The company operates as a distributor for independent agents, providing them with access to a variety of insurance offerings, including Medicare Advantage and Supplement Plans, life insurance, and ancillary products. Neishloss & Fleming is dedicated to supporting agents through comprehensive marketing resources and compliance assistance, which enables them to effectively serve their clients. With a workforce of 11-50 employees, the company has established itself as a significant player in the Medicare market, emphasizing partnership and agent success. Their tools, such as the MedicareCENTER and various agent programs, are designed to enhance the operational efficiency of agents in the competitive insurance landscape.
15. Insurance Services of Zelienople PA
- Website: zelieinsurance.com
- Ownership type: Family Owned
- Headquarters: Zelienople, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
- Founded year: 1980
- Headcount: 11-50
- LinkedIn: insurance-services-of-zelienople-pa
Insurance Services of Zelienople, LLC is a family-owned insurance agency based in Zelienople, Pennsylvania, established in 1980. The agency specializes in a variety of insurance products, prominently featuring health insurance, life insurance, and employee benefits. They cater to both individual consumers and businesses, emphasizing personalized service to assist clients in understanding and selecting the right insurance options. Their team of licensed sales representatives is dedicated to providing tailored advice, ensuring clients make informed decisions about their coverage. Operating mainly in Western Pennsylvania and Ohio, the agency has developed a strong local presence and a reputation for customer service. They work with major insurance carriers, allowing them to offer a range of plans that meet the specific needs of their clients. Their commitment to service is reflected in numerous positive testimonials from satisfied customers, highlighting their knowledgeable staff and supportive approach.
16. AmeriHealth Caritas
- Website: amerihealthcaritas.com
- Ownership type: Private
- Headquarters: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
- Founded year: 1983
- Headcount: 10001+
- LinkedIn: the-amerihealth-mercy-family-of-companies
AmeriHealth Caritas, founded in 1983 and based in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, is a private health care provider that specializes in managed care solutions. The company offers a comprehensive range of services, including Medicaid managed care, Medicare plans, and behavioral health care. With over 40 years of experience, AmeriHealth Caritas has developed a strong focus on serving Medicaid and Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP) populations, aiming to remove barriers to care and improve health outcomes for those in need. Their health care solutions extend to individual and family health plans, long-term services and supports, and pharmacy benefits management. The company is dedicated to addressing social determinants of health and has implemented various outreach programs to support community health. AmeriHealth Caritas operates with a mission to help people access care, maintain wellness, and foster healthy communities, making it a vital entity in the health insurance industry.
17. United Integrity Group
- Website: unitedintegrity.com
- Ownership type: Private
- Headquarters: Quakertown, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
- Founded year: 2005
- Headcount: 1-10
- LinkedIn: united-integrity-group
United Integrity Group, Inc., based in Quakertown, Pennsylvania, is a private insurance agency founded in 2005. The company specializes in Medicare Supplement insurance, assisting individuals, especially those approaching retirement age, in understanding and selecting suitable Medicare coverage options. As a broker, United Integrity Group collaborates with numerous insurance carriers, ensuring clients receive personalized service tailored to their unique needs. They emphasize a no-cost approach to their services, meaning clients do not incur additional fees for the assistance provided. Over the years, United Integrity Group has built a reputation for empowering clients to make informed decisions about their health insurance, having served over 18,000 clients by 2021. Their commitment to ongoing support includes annual reviews of coverage options, ensuring clients remain well-informed as plans evolve annually.
18. Pinnacle Financial Services, Inc.
- Website: pfsinsurance.com
- Ownership type: Private
- Headquarters: Warminster, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 96%, Malawi 4%
- Latest funding: Other (Debt), $2.5M, February 2021
- Founded year: 2001
- Headcount: 11-50
- LinkedIn: pfsinsurance
Pinnacle Financial Services, Inc., founded in 2001 and based in Warminster, Pennsylvania, is a private insurance agency that specializes in a variety of insurance products. The company primarily focuses on Medicare, Annuities, Life Insurance, and ancillary health products. Pinnacle supports independent agents and brokers by providing them with essential training, resources, and a comprehensive product portfolio. This support is vital for agents navigating the complexities of health insurance sales. The company has also received funding, with a reported amount of $2.5 million in 2021, which underscores its growth and operational capabilities. Pinnacle's emphasis on technology and agent support positions it as a significant entity in the health insurance market, particularly for those targeting the senior demographic.
19. Burns & Burns Insurance
- Website: burnsandburns.com
- Ownership type: Family Owned
- Headquarters: Clarion, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
- Founded year: 1939
- Headcount: 51-200
- LinkedIn: burns-and-burns-associates-inc.
Burns & Burns Insurance is a family-owned insurance agency based in Clarion, Pennsylvania, with a history dating back to 1939. Over the past 80 years, the company has built a reputation for providing a comprehensive suite of insurance solutions tailored to both individual consumers and businesses. Their offerings include personal insurance, business insurance, and life and health insurance products. The agency prides itself on its customer service and community involvement, serving clients across multiple locations in Northwestern Pennsylvania. They provide various health insurance options, including Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement Insurance, indicating their engagement in the health insurance market. Despite being a smaller agency, their long-standing presence and commitment to client care reflect their relevance in the industry.
20. Body-Borneman Insurance, Inc.
- Website: body-borneman.com
- Ownership type: Family Owned
- Headquarters: Boyertown, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
- Founded year: 1962
- Headcount: 11-50
- LinkedIn: body-borneman-ins
Body-Borneman Insurance, Inc. is a family-owned independent insurance agency based in Boyertown, Pennsylvania. Founded in 1964, the agency has built a solid reputation by offering a wide range of insurance solutions, including personal, business, life, and group health insurance. With a dedicated team of insurance advisors, Body-Borneman focuses on providing tailored coverage that meets the unique needs of its clients. The agency serves a variety of areas in Southeastern Pennsylvania, including West Chester, Boyertown, Pottstown, and Phoenixville. Their life and group health insurance offerings are designed to protect clients' health, income, and savings from financial loss. Body-Borneman Insurance prides itself on its customer-first approach, ensuring that clients receive the guidance they need to make informed decisions about their insurance coverage. The agency has not reported any funding, indicating that it operates independently without external financial backing.
21. Ignitist Inc
- Website: ignitist.net
- Ownership type: Corporate
- Headquarters: Harleysville, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
- Latest funding: June 2024
- Founded year: 2019
- Headcount: 201-500
- LinkedIn: ignitist
Ignitist Inc, founded in 2019 and based in Harleysville, Pennsylvania, is a healthcare distribution company dedicated to improving access to health insurance for low-income individuals, seniors, and disabled Americans. The company operates as a direct-to-consumer platform, focusing on Medicare Advantage plans and Dual Eligible Special Needs Plans (DSNPs). Ignitist employs a tech-enabled approach, utilizing licensed tele-sales agents to facilitate member acquisition and conversion. Their mission centers on helping underserved populations navigate the complexities of healthcare benefits, ensuring they receive the coverage they need. Ignitist collaborates with various health insurers and community organizations to enhance outreach and education, aiming to raise awareness about available benefits. Their commitment to social responsibility is evident in their operational strategies, which prioritize the needs of vulnerable groups in the healthcare system.
22. Turner Insurance Agency Inc
- Website: turnerinsurance.com
- Ownership type: Family Owned
- Headquarters: Harrisville, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Founded year: 1954
- Headcount: 1-10
- LinkedIn: turner-insurance-agency-inc
Turner Insurance Agency Inc, established in 1954, is a family-owned insurance agency based in Harrisville, Pennsylvania. With a small team of 1-10 employees, the agency has built a reputation for providing personalized service and tailored insurance solutions. They offer a variety of insurance products, including auto, home, business, life, and health insurance. Their health insurance services cater to individuals, families, and small businesses, assisting clients in navigating the complexities of health insurance options. The agency emphasizes quality education for its staff to stay updated on industry changes, ensuring clients receive informed guidance. Turner Insurance Agency Inc operates primarily in Western Pennsylvania and Eastern Ohio, focusing on building long-term relationships with clients through exceptional customer service.
23. St Marys Insurance Agency & Affiliates
- Website: stmarysagency.com
- Ownership type: Private
- Headquarters: Saint Marys, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
- Founded year: 1932
- Headcount: 11-50
- LinkedIn: st-marys-insurance-inc
St Marys Insurance Agency & Affiliates, based in Saint Marys, Pennsylvania, has been serving clients since 1932. With a team of approximately 20 employees, the agency operates from eight locations across Pennsylvania and New York. They provide a comprehensive range of insurance solutions, including personal, business, and employee benefits insurance. Their offerings include individual health insurance, which is part of their personal insurance suite. As an independent agency, they represent multiple insurance companies, allowing them to present various coverage options tailored to the unique needs of individuals, families, and businesses. Their commitment to customer service has earned them several awards, including recognition as an Erie Insurance Elite Award winner. This reflects their dedication to providing quality service and support to their clients.
24. Michael A. Starr Insurance, Inc.
- Website: insurewithstarr.com
- Ownership type: Private
- Headquarters: Chambersburg, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
- Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
- Founded year: 1989
- Headcount: 11-50
- LinkedIn: michael-a.-starr-insurance-inc.
Michael A. Starr Insurance, Inc., founded in 1989, is a private insurance agency based in Chambersburg, Pennsylvania. With a team of 11 to 50 employees, the agency specializes in a wide array of insurance products, including auto, home, business, life, and health insurance. The company serves individual consumers and businesses, helping them manage risks and protect their assets. As an independent agency, Starr Insurance Inc. is not tied to any single insurance provider, allowing them to offer competitive coverage options from a selection of financially strong and reputable insurance carriers. This independence enables them to tailor insurance solutions to meet the specific needs of their clients. The agency has built a solid reputation in the local market, serving over 18,000 individuals and businesses across Pennsylvania and neighboring states. Their commitment to customer service is reflected in their growth, primarily driven by referrals from satisfied clients. They also provide a range of policy services, including online billing and claims support, enhancing the customer experience.
Individual Health Insurance Insights: Key Companies in Pennsylvania
Company | Headquarter | Size | Founded | Ownership |
---|---|---|---|---|
AmeriHealth Administrators | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 501-1000 | 1988 | Corporate |
Highmark Blueshield | Allentown, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 11-50 | 1930 | Private |
Jefferson Health Plans | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 501-1000 | 1984 | Private |
Youngs Insurance Services, INC | Collegeville, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 11-50 | 1997 | Family Owned |
Main Line Benefits | Malvern, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 1-10 | 2021 | Private |
Fringe Benefit ServicesPA | Sharon, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 11-50 | 1970 | Family Owned |
Custom Benefit Plans Inc. | Willow Grove, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 11-50 | 1998 | Private |
NTI Group | Lancaster, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 11-50 | 2002 | Corporate |
Gallen Insurance | Shillington, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 11-50 | 1957 | Corporate |
URL Insurance Group | Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 11-50 | 1986 | Family Owned |
HTA Insurance Services | Exton, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 11-50 | 1976 | Private |
Robert J. Stillwell Agency | Spring House, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 11-50 | 1968 | Family Owned |
BGA Insurance Group | West Conshohocken, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 11-50 | 2008 | Private |
Neishloss & Fleming, LLC | Canonsburg, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 11-50 | 1982 | Corporate |
Insurance Services of Zelienople PA | Zelienople, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 11-50 | 1980 | Family Owned |
AmeriHealth Caritas | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 10001+ | 1983 | Private |
United Integrity Group | Quakertown, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 1-10 | 2005 | Private |
Pinnacle Financial Services, Inc. | Warminster, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 11-50 | 2001 | Private |
Burns & Burns Insurance | Clarion, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 51-200 | 1939 | Family Owned |
Body-Borneman Insurance, Inc. | Boyertown, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 11-50 | 1962 | Family Owned |
Ignitist Inc | Harleysville, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 201-500 | 2019 | Corporate |
Turner Insurance Agency Inc | Harrisville, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 1-10 | 1954 | Family Owned |
St Marys Insurance Agency & Affiliates | Saint Marys, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 11-50 | 1932 | Private |
Michael A. Starr Insurance, Inc. | Chambersburg, Pennsylvania, United States (USA) | 11-50 | 1989 | Private |
Want to Find More Individual Health Insurance Companies?
If you want to find more companies that offer plans such as Medicare, supplemental insurance, and family coverage you can do so with Inven. This list was built with Inven and there are hundreds of companies like these globally.With Inven you'll also get to know the company's:- Detailed Ownership: Who owns the company? Is it a public or private company? What is the ownership structure?
- Contact data: Who are the founders and CEO's? What are their emails and phone numbers?
- Financials: How do these companies perform financially? What are their revenues and profit margins?
...and a lot more!
Trusted by 700+ companies

















