Medicare supplement insurance companies in Pennsylvania help seniors cover healthcare costs that Medicare doesn't fully address, such as deductibles and copayments. This industry includes a mix of private agencies and brokers, focusing on providing tailored insurance solutions. With an aging population and rising healthcare expenses, the demand for comprehensive coverage is increasing. Additionally, the regulatory environment is evolving, pushing companies to innovate and offer more flexible plans. While traditional options remain prevalent, there's a shift towards technology-driven services and user-friendly platforms, making it easier for seniors to access information and plan their healthcare expenses effectively.

The listed companies showcase a range of sizes and establishments from family-owned firms to larger agencies, headquartered in various locations across Pennsylvania. Founded between 1932 and 2021, they specialize in Medicare supplement options and related services. Most companies employ a personalized approach, guiding clients towards suitable coverage while ensuring comprehensive support through multiple plan choices. This unique blend of experience and community-focused service creates a dynamic offering for Pennsylvania residents seeking Medicare solutions.

Continue reading to uncover more about Pennsylvania's top medicare supplement insurance companies.

Top 22 Medicare Supplement Insurance Companies in Pennsylvania

1. BGA Insurance Group

• Website: bgainsurance.net
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: West Conshohocken, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 2008
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: bga-insurance-group

BGA Insurance Group, founded in 2008 and based in West Conshohocken, Pennsylvania, is a private insurance agency that specializes in Medicare and retirement planning services. With a team of 36 employees, the company is dedicated to assisting seniors and their families in understanding and navigating their healthcare options. BGA offers a variety of insurance products, including Medicare Supplement Insurance, Medicare Advantage, and life insurance, among others. Their approach is characterized by personalized consultations, where licensed agents work closely with clients to identify the best insurance plans tailored to individual needs. The agency prides itself on providing free consultations, ensuring that clients receive guidance without financial obligation. BGA Insurance Group has built a reputation for attentive service, as evidenced by numerous positive testimonials from satisfied clients who appreciate the agency's commitment to their well-being and financial security.

2. United Integrity Group

• Website: unitedintegrity.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Quakertown, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 2005
• Headcount: 1-10
• LinkedIn: united-integrity-group

United Integrity Group, Inc., based in Quakertown, Pennsylvania, is an insurance agency founded in 2005. The company specializes in Medicare Supplement insurance, assisting individuals, particularly those approaching retirement, in understanding and selecting suitable Medicare coverage. As a broker, United Integrity Group collaborates with numerous insurance carriers, ensuring clients have access to a variety of plans without incurring additional costs. Their approach is centered on personalized service, empowering clients to make informed decisions about their healthcare coverage. The agency has built a reputation for its commitment to client satisfaction, having served over 18,000 clients by 2021. Their team is dedicated to staying updated on the latest Medicare options and changes, providing clients with annual reviews to ensure they maintain the best coverage for their needs.

3. Youngs Insurance Services, INC

• Website: yisonline.com
• Ownership type: Family Owned
• Headquarters: Collegeville, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1997
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: youngs-insurance-services-inc

Youngs Insurance Services, INC, based in Collegeville, Pennsylvania, is a family-owned insurance brokerage that has been serving clients since 1997. The firm specializes in health and life insurance products, with a strong emphasis on Medicare plans, including Medicare Supplement insurance, Medicare Advantage, and Medicare Part D. Youngs Insurance Services prides itself on offering personalized assistance, ensuring that clients receive tailored advice to navigate their insurance options. The company represents multiple organizations, providing a range of products to meet the needs of its clientele. Their approach includes annual reviews of coverage, maintaining close relationships with clients, and acting as advocates in resolving issues with healthcare providers and insurers. This dedication to customer service and expertise in Medicare-related products underscores their relevance in the insurance industry.

4. Fringe Benefit ServicesPA

• Website: fringebenefitservices.com
• Ownership type: Family Owned
• Headquarters: Sharon, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Founded year: 1970
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: fringe-benefit-servicespa

Fringe Benefit ServicesPA, based in Sharon, Pennsylvania, is a family-owned insurance agency that has been serving clients since 1970. Originally known as Wallace & Associates, the company has built a reputation for providing a wide range of insurance products, including health, life, and disability insurance. They cater to both individual consumers and businesses, emphasizing personalized service and attention to detail. The agency specializes in Medicare planning, offering clients guidance through the complexities of Medicare options, including Medicare Supplement Insurance Plans and Medicare Advantage Plans. They represent several well-known insurance carriers, allowing them to offer a variety of products tailored to meet the unique needs of their clients. Their commitment to education is evident through the resources they provide, such as Medicare FAQs and educational videos, which help clients make informed decisions about their insurance needs.

5. Neishloss & Fleming, LLC

• Website: neishloss.com
• Ownership type: Corporate
• Headquarters: Canonsburg, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Latest funding: January 2018
• Founded year: 1982
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: neishloss-%26-fleming-inc.

Neishloss & Fleming, LLC, based in Canonsburg, Pennsylvania, is an insurance agency that has been serving the Medicare market since 1982. The company specializes in Medicare and health-related products, providing independent agents with access to a range of insurance offerings, including Medicare Advantage and Supplement Plans, life insurance, and ancillary products. Neishloss & Fleming is dedicated to supporting agents by offering marketing resources, compliance assistance, and tools to enhance their business operations. Their commitment to agent success is evident in their extensive training programs and resources designed to help agents navigate the complexities of the insurance industry. With a workforce of 11-50 employees, Neishloss & Fleming has established itself as a significant distributor of Medicare plans, emphasizing a partnership approach with agents to foster growth and success in the senior market.

6. Custom Benefit Plans Inc.

• Website: custombenefitplans.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Willow Grove, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1998
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: custom-benefit-plans-inc

Custom Benefit Plans Inc. (CBPI), founded in 1998 and based in Willow Grove, Pennsylvania, is an insurance agency that specializes in health insurance, life insurance, and annuities. With a dedicated team of professionals, CBPI aims to provide exceptional service to individuals, families, and businesses. The company emphasizes personalized solutions, helping clients manage risk and adapt their coverage as their needs evolve. Notably, CBPI offers Medicare plans, guiding clients through the enrollment process and assisting them in selecting the right supplemental coverage. They work with all major insurance carriers, ensuring clients have access to a wide array of options. Their commitment to customer service is evident in their approach to educating clients about their insurance choices and providing ongoing support. CBPI has not reported any funding, indicating a stable, self-sustaining business model.

7. URL Insurance Group

• Website: urlinsgroup.com
• Ownership type: Family Owned
• Headquarters: Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1986
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: url-insurance-group

URL Insurance Group, based in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, is a family-owned insurance brokerage founded in 1986. With a workforce of approximately 50 employees, the company has built a reputation for providing a wide range of insurance products, including health, life, and Medicare insurance. URL Insurance Group serves individuals, families, and businesses, focusing on personalized service to meet their clients' unique needs. They offer Medicare Advantage Plans, Medicare Supplement Insurance Plans, and Part D Prescription Drug Plans, showcasing their commitment to the Medicare market. The company prides itself on its collaborative approach, working closely with insurance agents and clients to ensure that they find the best insurance solutions. URL Insurance Group partners with over 100 carriers, which allows them to offer a variety of options tailored to their clients' requirements. Their long-standing presence in the industry and dedication to client service make them a notable player in the Medicare supplement insurance space.

8. Robert J. Stillwell Agency

• Website: robertjstillwell.com
• Ownership type: Family Owned
• Headquarters: Spring House, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1968
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: robert-j-stillwell-agency

The Robert J. Stillwell Agency, established in 1968, is a family-owned insurance agency based in Spring House, Pennsylvania. With a dedicated team of 23 employees, the agency has built a reputation for providing personalized insurance solutions to individuals and families. They offer a variety of insurance products, including life, health, and Medicare plans, with a particular focus on Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement (Medigap) insurance. The agency prides itself on delivering tailored services that meet the unique needs of its clients, ensuring they receive the right coverage for their circumstances. Their proactive approach includes annual policy reviews to adapt to changing client needs, demonstrating a commitment to ongoing client support and satisfaction. The agency operates independently, representing multiple carriers, which allows them to prioritize client interests over those of any single insurance provider.

9. KKJ Consulting, LLC

• Website: kkjconsults.us
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Columbus, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Founded year: 2013
• Headcount: 1-10
• LinkedIn: kkj-consulting-llc

KKJ Consulting, LLC, founded in 2013 and based in Columbus, Pennsylvania, is a private consulting firm with a small team dedicated to providing specialized services in Medicare insurance consulting and health supplements. The firm focuses on helping individuals navigate the complexities of Medicare insurance, offering guidance to clients in Pennsylvania and New York. They represent multiple insurance companies, allowing them to present a range of options that cater to the unique needs and budgets of their clients. In addition to Medicare consulting, KKJ Consulting also offers health supplement products aimed at enhancing overall well-being. Their business consulting services leverage over 40 years of experience to assist businesses and non-profits in improving their operations. While they are active in the Medicare consulting space, they do not directly provide insurance products, which is a key aspect of the Medicare supplement insurance market.

10. Bayline Insurance Agency

• Website: baylineins.com
• Ownership type: Family Owned
• Headquarters: Port Allegany, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1932
• Headcount: 1-10
• LinkedIn: bayline-insurance-agency

Bayline Insurance Agency, established in 1932, is a family-owned independent insurance agency located in Port Allegany, Pennsylvania. The agency has a rich history, having evolved through generations of the Bayline family, with current leadership under J. Michael Bayline, who has expanded the agency's offerings over the years. Bayline Insurance Agency provides a range of insurance products, including life, auto, homeowners, and business insurance, alongside their Medicare supplement insurance services. They emphasize personalized service, helping clients navigate the complexities of insurance coverage to find the right fit for their needs. The agency employs a small team of licensed agents dedicated to client service, ensuring that customers receive the attention and expertise necessary for informed decision-making. Their involvement in Medicare supplement insurance is significant, as they assist clients aged 65 and over in understanding and selecting plans that complement their Medicare coverage, addressing out-of-pocket costs that Medicare does not cover.

11. Bost

• Website: bostbenefits.com
• Ownership type: Family Owned
• Headquarters: New Castle, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 2006
• Headcount: 51-200
• LinkedIn: bost-benefits

Bost Benefits, founded in 2006 and based in New Castle, Pennsylvania, is a family-owned company with a workforce of approximately 152 employees. With over 30 years of experience in the benefits industry, Bost specializes in providing comprehensive employee benefits solutions, including medical benefits planning and benefit education. They serve a wide range of clients, from individuals and families to organizations and Fortune 500 companies. Bost is particularly noted for its Medicare resources, offering no-cost assistance to Medicare-eligible individuals, helping them understand their options and navigate the complexities of Medicare. They represent 27 organizations and provide access to 95 products in their area, showcasing their involvement in the insurance sector. Bost's commitment to empowering clients through informed decision-making and support is a core aspect of their service philosophy.

12. Main Line Benefits

• Website: mlbenefitsco.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Malvern, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 2021
• Headcount: 1-10
• LinkedIn: financial-protections-services-corp

Main Line Benefits, based in Malvern, Pennsylvania, is an insurance agency that specializes in providing a variety of insurance services, including Medicare, health, supplemental, and life insurance. Founded in 2021, the company aims to assist individuals, families, small businesses, and Medicare beneficiaries in navigating the often complex insurance market. They emphasize personalized service, helping clients find plans that align with their needs and budgets. Main Line Benefits claims to work with over 180 providers, allowing them to offer a wide range of options to their clients. Their approach is centered on simplifying the insurance selection process, ensuring that clients understand their choices without incurring additional costs for their services. With a focus on community engagement and client education, they strive to build lasting relationships with their clients and support them in making informed decisions about their insurance needs.

13. Jefferson Health Plans

• Website: jeffersonhealthplans.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1984
• Headcount: 501-1000
• LinkedIn: jefferson-health-plans

Jefferson Health Plans, based in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, is a private health insurance provider that has been operational since 1984. The company specializes in offering a variety of health insurance products, including Medicare Advantage plans, Individual and Family plans, and Medicaid options. Jefferson Health Plans aims to provide affordable healthcare coverage, ensuring that individuals and families have access to necessary medical services while managing healthcare costs effectively. They have developed a significant network of providers, enhancing their service delivery in the regions they operate. As a marketing name for select products of Health Partners Plans, Inc., Jefferson Health Plans is committed to supporting the health and wellness of its members through comprehensive coverage options and additional benefits that cater to the needs of Medicare beneficiaries.

14. Insurance Services of Zelienople PA

• Website: zelieinsurance.com
• Ownership type: Family Owned
• Headquarters: Zelienople, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1980
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: insurance-services-of-zelienople-pa

Insurance Services of Zelienople, LLC is a family-owned insurance agency based in Zelienople, Pennsylvania, established in 1980. The agency specializes in a variety of insurance products, including health, life, and employee benefits, with a strong emphasis on Medicare solutions. They serve both individual consumers and businesses, primarily in Western Pennsylvania and Ohio. The agency prides itself on providing personalized service, helping clients understand their insurance options, particularly in the complex area of Medicare. Their team of licensed sales representatives is dedicated to guiding clients through the intricacies of Medicare Supplement and Advantage plans, ensuring that clients make informed decisions. The agency's commitment to customer service is reflected in numerous positive testimonials from clients who have successfully navigated their Medicare options with the agency's assistance.

15. Highmark Blueshield

• Website: highmarkblueshield.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Allentown, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Founded year: 1930
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: highmark-blueshield

Highmark Blueshield, based in Allentown, Pennsylvania, is a private health insurance provider founded in 1930. The company offers a variety of health plans, including individual and family plans, Medicare, Medicaid, and CHIP. Highmark serves both consumers and businesses, aiming to make healthcare more accessible and affordable. Their Medicare offerings include Medicare Advantage plans and Dual Special Needs Plans (D-SNP), which cater to specific needs of eligible individuals. Highmark also emphasizes mental health support services, reflecting a holistic approach to health management. The company operates under the Blue Cross Blue Shield Association, which enhances its credibility and reach in the health insurance market.

16. The Senior Resource Group, LLC

• Website: theseniorresourcegroup.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 2008
• Headcount: 501-1000
• LinkedIn: the-senior-resource-group

The Senior Resource Group, LLC, founded in 2008 and based in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, operates as a field marketing organization dedicated to empowering independent insurance agents. With a workforce of approximately 501-1000 employees, the company has established itself as a vital resource in the insurance industry. They specialize in Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement, life insurance, and ancillary health products. By collaborating with national carriers, The Senior Resource Group provides agents with access to a wide array of insurance products, along with essential training and marketing assistance. Their commitment to agent success is evident in their comprehensive support systems, which include cutting-edge technology and ongoing education tailored to the evolving needs of the insurance market.

17. Burns & Burns Insurance

• Website: burnsandburns.com
• Ownership type: Family Owned
• Headquarters: Clarion, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1939
• Headcount: 51-200
• LinkedIn: burns-and-burns-associates-inc.

Burns & Burns Insurance, established in 1939, is a family-owned insurance agency based in Clarion, Pennsylvania. With a workforce of approximately 52 employees, the agency has built a reputation for providing a comprehensive suite of insurance solutions that cater to both personal and business needs. Their offerings include home, auto, life, and health insurance, with a specific focus on Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement Insurance. This indicates their active participation in the Medicare market, helping clients navigate their options and secure appropriate coverage. The agency prides itself on its customer service, treating clients like family and ensuring they receive personalized attention. Over the years, Burns & Burns has maintained a strong local presence with multiple locations across Northwestern Pennsylvania, further solidifying their commitment to the community and their clients' insurance needs.

18. Patrick J. Kelly Insurance Group

• Website: kellyins.com
• Ownership type: Family Owned
• Headquarters: Montgomery, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1984
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: patrick-j-kelly-insurance-group

Patrick J. Kelly Insurance Group, LLC is a family-owned insurance agency based in Trappe, Pennsylvania, founded in 1984. With a team of 20 employees, the agency provides a range of insurance products, including homeowners, auto, life, health, and commercial insurance. They also offer Medicare supplement plans, catering to the needs of seniors in their community. The agency prides itself on personal service and building long-term relationships with clients, many of whom have been with them for generations. Their independent status allows them to represent multiple insurance carriers, providing clients with various options and competitive rates. The company has a strong local presence, serving areas such as Collegeville, Limerick, and Royersford, and emphasizes the importance of tailored solutions to manage risks and protect assets.

19. HTA Insurance Services

• Website: hta-insurance.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Exton, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1976
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: hta-insurance-services

HTA Insurance Services, based in Exton, Pennsylvania, is a private insurance agency that specializes in Medicare and Property & Casualty Insurance. Founded in 1976, the company has evolved significantly over the years, particularly shifting its focus to Medicare in 1998. HTA prides itself on simplifying complex insurance decisions for both individuals and businesses. They provide personalized consultation and enrollment assistance, ensuring clients understand their options and make informed choices. The agency represents over 20 insurance carriers, which allows them to offer a variety of plans tailored to the unique needs of their clients. HTA's team is known for its extensive knowledge and commitment to ongoing education, which enhances their ability to serve clients effectively. The company has received numerous positive reviews, highlighting their compassionate service and dedication to client satisfaction. HTA continues to grow under the leadership of Tracy Keesey, who has been instrumental in expanding the company's reach and capabilities in the insurance market.

20. Pinnacle Financial Services, Inc.

• Website: pfsinsurance.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Warminster, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 96%, Malawi 4%
• Latest funding: Other (Debt), $2.5M, February 2021
• Founded year: 2001
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: pfsinsurance

Pinnacle Financial Services, Inc., founded in 2001 and based in Warminster, Pennsylvania, is a private insurance agency that specializes in a broad array of insurance products, including Medicare supplements, annuities, and life insurance. The company primarily serves independent agents and brokers, providing them with essential training, resources, and a comprehensive product portfolio to effectively meet their clients' needs. Pinnacle has established a strong presence in the Medicare market, offering tools and technology designed to streamline the enrollment process for Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement plans. With a workforce of approximately 85 employees, the company has demonstrated growth and adaptability in the insurance industry. In February 2021, Pinnacle secured $2.5 million in funding, which underscores its ongoing commitment to enhancing its service offerings and operational capabilities.

21. Flexible Benefits Plans, Inc. Powered by FNA

• Website: flexiben.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Valley Forge, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1986
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: flexible-benefits-plans-inc.

Flexible Benefits Plans, Inc. Powered by FNA, based in Valley Forge, Pennsylvania, has been operational since 1986. This private insurance brokerage specializes in group benefits and a range of insurance products, including health, dental, life, and disability insurance. The company primarily serves brokers and business associations, providing essential support in navigating the complexities of insurance regulations and compliance. Their offerings include Medicare products, indicating their involvement in the Medicare insurance sector. FBP emphasizes a flexible service model tailored to the needs of their partners, which includes ACA compliance assistance, COBRA administration, and various ancillary coverages. With a dedicated service team, they aim to foster strong relationships within the insurance community, particularly in Pennsylvania and New Jersey.

22. Gallen Insurance

• Website: galleninsurance.com
• Ownership type: Corporate
• Headquarters: Shillington, Pennsylvania, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Latest funding: August 2023
• Founded year: 1957
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: gallen-insurance

Gallen Insurance, based in Shillington, Pennsylvania, has been a fixture in the insurance industry since its founding in 1957. With a team of 22 employees, the agency specializes in a wide array of insurance solutions, including personal, business, and employee benefits insurance. Notably, Gallen Insurance provides Medicare options, catering to the needs of individuals aged 65 and older, as well as those with disabilities. Their commitment to client service is evident through their independent agency model, which allows them to offer various carrier options tailored to client needs. Gallen Insurance has received recognition in the local community, including the Berks County People’s Choice Award, underscoring their reputation as a trusted provider. The agency's focus on personalized service and community involvement positions it as a relevant player in the Medicare supplement insurance market.

Medicare Supplement Insurance Insights: Key Companies in Pennsylvania

Want to Find More Medicare Supplement Insurance Companies?

With Inven you'll also get to know the company's:

• Detailed Ownership: Who owns the company? Is it a public or private company? What is the ownership structure?
• Contact data: Who are the founders and CEO's? What are their emails and phone numbers?
• Financials: How do these companies perform financially? What are their revenues and profit margins?

...and a lot more!