Medicare supplement insurance in Indiana addresses gaps in healthcare coverage for seniors, offering additional financial support to those enrolled in Medicare. Companies in this sector vary from smaller local agencies to larger, nationally recognized firms. They provide products like Medicare Supplement Plans, Medicare Advantage Plans, and prescription drug coverage tailored for seniors' specific needs. As the demand for Medicare products continues to grow, firms are increasingly utilizing technology to streamline enrollment processes and enhance customer engagement, promising a more accessible future in healthcare insurance services for this demographic.


The companies listed here range from small family-owned agencies to larger firms, primarily located across Indiana's major cities. Founded between 1939 and 2007, many specialize in Medicare-related products, aiming to support seniors throughout their healthcare journey. Sizes vary from 1-10 employees to over 500, reflecting different operational capacities and client outreach strategies in serving the Medicare market.


Continue reading to explore the top medicare supplement insurance companies in Indiana.


Top 22 Medicare Supplement Insurance Companies in Indiana


1. Senior Connection


Senior Connection, based in Evansville, Indiana, is a private insurance agency founded in 1991. The company specializes in Medicare and related insurance services, catering primarily to seniors. They offer a variety of products, including Medicare Supplement Plans, Medicare Advantage Plans, Medicare Prescription Drug Plans, life insurance, long-term care, and major medical insurance. With a dedicated team of 11 to 50 employees, Senior Connection prides itself on providing clear guidance and support to help seniors navigate their healthcare options. Their approach emphasizes education and personalized service, ensuring clients understand their choices and can make informed decisions. Over the years, they have built a reputation as a trusted resource for Medicare-related insurance, conducting educational seminars and offering free consultations to assist clients in selecting the right plans for their needs.


2. Senior Care Insurance Services

  • Website: scisnwi.com
  • Ownership type: Private
  • Headquarters: Merrillville, Indiana, United States (USA)
  • Founded year: 1987
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn: scisnwi

Senior Care Insurance Services (SCIS) is an insurance agency based in Merrillville, Indiana, founded in 1987 by twin brothers Mike and Fred Ulayyet. The agency specializes in Medicare-related insurance products, including Medicare Supplement Plans, Medicare Advantage Plans, and Medicare Prescription Drug Plans. With a focus on serving seniors and individuals with disabilities, SCIS has built a reputation for personalized service and customer satisfaction. The company operates five locations across Northwest Indiana, allowing them to cater to a broad client base. Their independent broker status enables them to offer competitive rates and a variety of options tailored to individual needs. Over the years, SCIS has supported thousands of clients, establishing a strong presence in the Medicare insurance market.


3. American Health


American Health, also known as Health Market Group, is a family-owned health insurance agency based in Fort Wayne, Indiana. Founded in 1977, the company has built a reputation for providing a range of health insurance products tailored to individuals and families. Their offerings include individual health insurance, short-term medical plans, dental and vision insurance, and notably, Medicare supplements and Medicare Advantage plans. With a commitment to personalized service, American Health assists clients in understanding their options and navigating the application process. The agency prides itself on its experienced team, which is dedicated to ensuring clients find suitable coverage that meets their needs. Their focus on senior products, including Part D drug benefits and final expense plans, highlights their commitment to serving the Medicare demographic. American Health has maintained strong relationships with various carriers, allowing them to offer current and relevant health insurance products to their clients.


4. VanVleet Insurance

  • Website: vanvleetinsurance.com
  • Ownership type: Family Owned
  • Headquarters: Richmond, Indiana, United States (USA)
  • Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
  • Founded year: 1981
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn: vanvleet-insurance

VanVleet Insurance, based in Richmond, Indiana, has been a staple in the insurance industry since its founding in 1981. With a team of 22 employees, this family-owned agency specializes in a variety of insurance products, including personal, business, farm, life, and notably, Medicare insurance. Their approach is characterized by a personal touch, ensuring that clients receive tailored solutions that meet their specific needs. Over the years, VanVleet Insurance has built a reputation for reliability and community involvement, hosting events such as Medicare open enrollment sessions to educate clients about their options. This proactive engagement in the Medicare sector highlights their dedication to serving the needs of seniors and those eligible for Medicare, reinforcing their role as a trusted insurance provider in the local community.


5. The Sanders Insurance Agency, Inc.


The Sanders Insurance Agency, Inc., based in Mishawaka, Indiana, has been a trusted name in the insurance industry since its establishment in 1984. This family-owned agency specializes in life and health insurance solutions tailored to the needs of individuals, families, and businesses. With a strong emphasis on Medicare and long-term care, the agency provides personalized services that help clients navigate their insurance options effectively. They work with multiple nationally recognized insurance carriers, offering a variety of plans to meet the unique needs of their clients. The agency prides itself on its commitment to education, providing resources such as consumer forms and educational Medicare videos to empower clients in their decision-making process. Their team includes certified Medicare professionals who bring years of experience and a dedication to client service, ensuring that clients receive the guidance they need to choose the right insurance products. The Sanders Agency continues to adapt to the evolving healthcare landscape, maintaining relevance in the industry through ongoing education and community involvement.


6. Bloom

  • Website: bloomthrives.com
  • Ownership type: Private
  • Headquarters: Bloomington, Indiana, United States (USA)
  • Employee distribution: United States (USA) 99%
  • Founded year: 2007
  • Headcount: 501-1000
  • LinkedIn: bloominsurance

Bloom, founded in 2007 and based in Bloomington, Indiana, is a private health insurance service provider that specializes in Medicare insurance plans. With a workforce of approximately 688 employees, Bloom focuses on connecting Medicare beneficiaries with suitable health insurance options. The company offers a range of services, including telesales for health insurance enrollment, a technology platform designed for member engagement, and health activation initiatives aimed at improving access to care. Bloom's approach emphasizes personalized interactions and support throughout the enrollment process, ensuring that beneficiaries feel confident in their choices. Their Ascend platform enhances the enrollment experience by providing real-time tools for quoting and member engagement. Bloom has handled millions of calls and enrollments since its inception, showcasing its significant involvement in the Medicare insurance industry.


7. Gordon Marketing

  • Website: gordonmarketing.com
  • Ownership type: Family Owned
  • Headquarters: Noblesville, Indiana, United States (USA)
  • Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
  • Founded year: 1980
  • Headcount: 201-500
  • LinkedIn: gordon-marketing

Gordon Marketing, founded in 1980 and based in Noblesville, Indiana, is a family-owned insurance broker and Field Marketing Office (FMO). The company has built a reputation for providing comprehensive support to independent insurance agents across various insurance products, including Medicare, health, life, and annuities. With a workforce of approximately 136 employees, Gordon Marketing emphasizes training and resources to empower agents in their sales efforts. Their Medicare division offers a range of products, including Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement plans from well-known carriers like Humana and United American. The company prides itself on its personal approach, fostering relationships with agents through face-to-face interactions and ongoing education. This commitment to agent success is reflected in their extensive training programs and marketing tools designed to help agents thrive in a competitive market.


8. Renaissance Life and Health Insurance Company of America

  • Website: renaissancebenefits.com
  • Ownership type: Private
  • Headquarters: Indianapolis, Indiana, United States (USA)
  • Employee distribution: United States (USA) 98%, Georgia 2%
  • Founded year: 2007
  • Headcount: 201-500
  • LinkedIn: renaissancebenefits

Renaissance Life and Health Insurance Company of America, based in Indianapolis, Indiana, was founded in 2007. The company operates as a private entity with a workforce of approximately 240 employees. It specializes in health benefits, providing a variety of insurance products that include dental, vision, life, and disability coverage. Their services cater to individuals, families, and businesses, aiming to help clients manage healthcare costs and secure financial stability through comprehensive insurance solutions. Notably, Renaissance also offers Medicare Supplement plans, which are designed to fill the gaps in coverage for Medicare beneficiaries. This involvement in the Medicare sector reflects their commitment to addressing the needs of seniors and those eligible for Medicare. The company has not reported any recent funding, indicating a stable operational model without external financial backing.


9. Bloom Insurance


Bloom Insurance Agency, founded in 2007 and based in Bloomington, Indiana, is a private healthcare services firm that specializes in Medicare insurance enrollment. With a workforce of over 500 employees, the company is dedicated to assisting Medicare beneficiaries through personalized support and advanced technology solutions. Bloom Insurance focuses on enhancing member engagement and improving access to care, which are critical components in the Medicare landscape. Their services include benefit counseling, plan comparisons, and a unique approach to enrollment that emphasizes member interaction and satisfaction. The company has successfully handled millions of calls and enrollments since its inception, showcasing its operational capacity and commitment to the Medicare community.


10. The Bedrock Group

  • Website: bedrockfg.com
  • Ownership type: Private
  • Headquarters: New Albany, Indiana, United States (USA)
  • Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
  • Founded year: 2018
  • Headcount: 51-200
  • LinkedIn: myseniorsolutionsllc

The Bedrock Group, based in New Albany, Indiana, is a private insurance agency founded in 2018. With a team of approximately 38 employees, the company specializes in various insurance services, including Medicare planning, retirement planning, life insurance, and property and casualty insurance. Their Medicare division, Senior Solutions, was created to help seniors transition into Medicare and navigate their options effectively. The Bedrock Group prides itself on providing personalized service and education to empower clients in making informed decisions about their insurance needs. They conduct annual Medicare Benefit Reviews to ensure clients receive optimal coverage tailored to their unique situations. The agency is veteran and first-responder-owned, which adds a layer of commitment to service and community. They operate across multiple states, providing local support to clients, and are contracted with top-tier insurance carriers to offer a variety of plans. Their focus on Medicare and retirement solutions positions them as a relevant player in the insurance industry.


11. Advise Insurance

  • Website: adviseinsurance.com
  • Ownership type: Private Equity
  • Headquarters: Bloomington, Indiana, United States (USA)
  • Latest funding: Series A, $100.0M, March 2021
  • Founded year: 2018
  • Headcount: 51-200
  • LinkedIn: advise-insurance-agency

Advise Insurance, known as Bloom, is a health insurance agency based in Bloomington, Indiana, founded in 2018. The company specializes in Medicare insurance enrollment and member engagement services, providing personalized support to Medicare beneficiaries. Bloom's approach combines technology with human interaction to simplify the enrollment process, ensuring that clients receive the guidance they need to make informed decisions about their Medicare coverage. The agency operates through a digital platform designed to enhance the enrollment experience, offering services such as benefit counseling and plan comparisons. In 2021, Bloom secured $100 million in Series A funding, which underscores its growth potential and commitment to improving the Medicare enrollment process. With a team of approximately 62 employees, Bloom aims to connect individuals with suitable Medicare insurance plans, focusing on member engagement and retention.


12. Ash Brokerage

  • Website: ashbrokerage.com
  • Ownership type: Corporate
  • Headquarters: Fort Wayne, Indiana, United States (USA)
  • Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
  • Latest funding: May 2022
  • Founded year: 1971
  • Headcount: 201-500
  • LinkedIn: ash-brokerage

Ash Brokerage, founded in 1971 and based in Fort Wayne, Indiana, is an insurance brokerage firm that specializes in providing a wide range of insurance solutions. With a workforce of approximately 527 employees, the company primarily serves financial professionals, including advisors and wealth managers. Their offerings include life insurance, retirement planning, disability insurance, long-term care, and notably, Medicare solutions. Ash Brokerage positions itself as a partner to financial professionals, equipping them with the necessary tools and resources to help their clients navigate complex insurance needs. They represent over 80 top-rated insurance carriers, which allows them to offer a variety of options tailored to client requirements. Their commitment to education and support is evident through their extensive resources, including webinars, case studies, and a concept library designed to enhance the capabilities of their partners. While they do not report any recent funding, their long-standing presence in the industry and focus on innovation suggest a stable and evolving business model.


13. Anton Insurance Agency a Shepherd Insurance Partner


Anton Insurance Agency, a Shepherd Insurance Partner, is a family-owned insurance agency based in Chesterton, Indiana, with a history dating back to 1957. As part of Shepherd Insurance, one of the largest independent insurance agencies in the United States, Anton Insurance Agency provides a wide array of insurance products, including commercial and personal insurance, employee benefits, and Medicare insurance. Their Medicare services include assistance with Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans, Medicare Advantage plans, and prescription drug plans. The agency prides itself on building relationships and offering tailored solutions to meet the unique needs of its clients. With a team of licensed agents, they focus on helping clients understand their Medicare options without any cost for their services, reflecting their commitment to customer support and education in the Medicare insurance space.


14. Shepherd Insurance


Shepherd Insurance, founded in 1977 and headquartered in Carmel, Indiana, operates as an independent insurance agency. With a workforce of over 500 employees across more than 40 offices in seven states, the company provides a wide array of insurance services, including commercial and personal insurance, employee benefits, and financial advisory services. Notably, Shepherd Insurance has a dedicated team for Medicare insurance, helping clients navigate the complexities of Medicare plans. Their agents are licensed in multiple states and are committed to offering tailored solutions that align with clients' health needs and budgets. The agency has built a reputation for customer service and relationship management, which is reflected in the testimonials from satisfied clients. Shepherd Insurance has also been recognized as one of the 50 largest independent insurance agencies in the country, showcasing its substantial presence in the industry.


15. Zeller Insurance

  • Website: zellerinsurance.com
  • Ownership type: Private
  • Headquarters: Columbus, Indiana, United States (USA)
  • Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
  • Founded year: 1972
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn: zeller-insurance-llc

Zeller Insurance, established in 1972 and based in Columbus, Indiana, operates as a private insurance agency. With a team of 11 to 50 employees, the company provides a variety of insurance products tailored to both individual consumers and businesses. Their offerings include homeowners, automobile, life, and benefits insurance, with a notable section dedicated to Medicare, health, long-term care, and dental insurance. Zeller Insurance aims to assist clients in managing risks and protecting their assets through customized insurance solutions. Their commitment to customer service is evident in their proactive approach and the emphasis on efficiency in processing claims and quotes. The agency has built a reputation for being a reliable partner for insurance needs in the local community, although specific details about their market share or competitive standing in the Medicare supplement sector are not readily available.


16. Oberlin Marketing

  • Website: oberlinmarketing.com
  • Ownership type: Corporate
  • Headquarters: Fort Wayne, Indiana, United States (USA)
  • Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
  • Latest funding: September 2021
  • Founded year: 1987
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn: oberlin-marketing

Oberlin Marketing, established in 1987 and based in Fort Wayne, Indiana, operates as an insurance brokerage dedicated to supporting insurance agents across the United States. The company specializes in a wide array of insurance products, including Medicare supplements, Medicare Advantage plans, and prescription drug plans. Oberlin Marketing prides itself on providing agents with high-quality products, comprehensive training, and marketing support, enabling them to effectively serve their clients. The firm has built a reputation in the Midwest for its commitment to agent service, offering resources such as application reviews, status updates, and advanced sales support. Their training center also provides continuing education classes, ensuring that agents remain informed about industry changes and compliance requirements. Oberlin Marketing's focus on agent support and education positions it as a significant player in the insurance brokerage market, particularly for those specializing in Medicare-related products.


17. Burkhart Insurance Agency

  • Website: burkhartinsurance.com
  • Ownership type: Private
  • Headquarters: Vincennes, Indiana, United States (USA)
  • Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
  • Founded year: 1988
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn: burkhartinsurance

Burkhart Insurance Agency, established in 1988, is a private insurance agency based in Vincennes, Indiana. With a team of 18 employees, the agency provides a variety of insurance products, including personal, commercial, and life insurance. They serve both individual consumers and businesses, helping clients manage risk through customized insurance solutions. Burkhart Insurance emphasizes customer service and operates multiple locations across Indiana and Illinois. Their offerings include Medicare Supplement insurance, which caters to the needs of seniors seeking additional coverage beyond standard Medicare. As an independent agency, Burkhart Insurance collaborates with several top-rated insurance companies, allowing them to shop for the best policies for their clients. Their commitment to community involvement and customer satisfaction is evident in their approach to insurance, where they prioritize building strong relationships with clients.


18. Independent Insurance Brokerage, LLC


Independent Insurance Brokerage, LLC, based in Carmel, Indiana, is a private insurance brokerage founded in 2020. The company specializes in providing a range of insurance products, including life insurance, disability insurance, long-term care, and Medicare. They primarily serve independent agents and financial services professionals, offering access to over 100 A-rated carriers. This extensive network allows agents to find suitable products for their clients while enhancing their financial practices through support in marketing, case design, and operational assistance. With a team boasting over 100 years of combined experience in the industry, Independent Insurance Brokerage aims to foster strong relationships with their agency partners, focusing on personalized service and expertise. Their commitment to empowering independent agents positions them as a resourceful entity in the insurance market, particularly in the Medicare segment.


19. Springer Insurance

  • Website: springerinsurance.com
  • Ownership type: Private
  • Headquarters: Sullivan, Indiana, United States (USA)
  • Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
  • Founded year: 1987
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn: springer-insurance

Springer Insurance, founded in 1987 and based in Sullivan, Indiana, is a private insurance agency that provides a wide array of insurance products. The company specializes in personal, commercial, health, life, crop, and farm insurance, catering to both individual consumers and businesses. With a dedicated team of 11 to 50 employees, Springer Insurance emphasizes personalized service, ensuring that clients receive tailored insurance solutions that meet their specific needs. Their offerings include Medicare Supplement insurance, which helps cover healthcare costs not included in standard Medicare plans. This positions them as a relevant player in the Medicare supplement market, particularly for clients looking for local, accessible service. The agency prides itself on its long-standing relationships with clients, often described as family-like, which enhances their reputation in the community. They operate without external funding, focusing on building a sustainable business model through customer satisfaction and local engagement.


20. Torian Insurance


Torian Insurance, based in Evansville, Indiana, is a private insurance agency that has been serving the community since 1923. With a team of 29 employees, the agency specializes in a wide range of personal and business insurance products, including Medicare Supplement Insurance. Torian Insurance prides itself on its customer-centric approach, offering tailored solutions to protect individuals, families, and businesses against various risks. The agency's long-standing history in the industry reflects its commitment to community engagement and ethical business practices. As an independent agency, Torian Insurance provides clients with access to multiple insurance options, ensuring that they receive the best coverage for their unique needs. Their focus on building relationships and understanding client goals positions them as a trusted partner in the insurance market.


21. Amstutz Insurance

  • Website: amstutzinsurance.com
  • Ownership type: Private
  • Headquarters: Fort Wayne, Indiana, United States (USA)
  • Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
  • Founded year: 1939
  • Headcount: 11-50
  • LinkedIn: amstutz-insurance

Amstutz Insurance, Inc. is a private insurance agency based in Fort Wayne, Indiana, with a history dating back to 1939. The agency operates multiple locations across Indiana and serves clients in Michigan, Ohio, and Florida. With a workforce of 11 to 50 employees, Amstutz Insurance specializes in a variety of insurance products, including auto, business, farm, home, life, and recreational vehicle insurance. Notably, they also provide financial planning products such as annuities, life insurance, and Medicare-related services. Their independent agency status allows them to represent multiple top-rated insurance carriers, enabling them to offer competitive rates and customized coverage options. The agency prides itself on delivering excellent customer service, leveraging over 350 years of combined insurance experience among its staff to assist clients in navigating the complexities of insurance planning.


22. Advocate Financial Life & Health Brokerage


Advocate Financial Life & Health Brokerage, founded in 2009 and based in Fort Wayne, Indiana, is an insurance marketing firm dedicated to enhancing the capabilities of independent insurance agents and financial advisors. The company specializes in a range of products, including life insurance, annuities, and notably, Medicare insurance. Advocate Financial prides itself on its innovative technology and strategic support, which are designed to help agents grow their businesses effectively. With a focus on Medicare, the firm collaborates with over 50 top insurance carriers, ensuring that agents have access to a wide array of Medicare plans. Additionally, Advocate Financial is involved in initiatives that support individuals with disabilities on Medicare, showcasing their commitment to making a positive impact in the community. Their extensive training programs and resources for agents further solidify their role in the Medicare insurance market.



Medicare Supplement Insurance Insights: Key Companies in Indiana


CompanyHeadquarterSizeFoundedOwnership
Senior ConnectionEvansville, Indiana, United States (USA)11-501991Private
Senior Care Insurance ServicesMerrillville, Indiana, United States (USA)11-501987Private
American HealthFort Wayne, Indiana, United States (USA)1-101977Family Owned
VanVleet InsuranceRichmond, Indiana, United States (USA)11-501981Family Owned
The Sanders Insurance Agency, Inc.Mishawaka, Indiana, United States (USA)1-101984Family Owned
BloomBloomington, Indiana, United States (USA)501-10002007Private
Gordon MarketingNoblesville, Indiana, United States (USA)201-5001980Family Owned
Renaissance Life and Health Insurance Company of AmericaIndianapolis, Indiana, United States (USA)201-5002007Private
Bloom InsuranceBloomington, Indiana, United States (USA)201-5002007Private
The Bedrock GroupNew Albany, Indiana, United States (USA)51-2002018Private
Advise InsuranceBloomington, Indiana, United States (USA)51-2002018Private Equity
Ash BrokerageFort Wayne, Indiana, United States (USA)201-5001971Corporate
Anton Insurance Agency a Shepherd Insurance PartnerChesterton, Indiana, United States (USA)11-501957Family Owned
Shepherd InsuranceCarmel, Indiana, United States (USA)501-10001977Corporate
Zeller InsuranceColumbus, Indiana, United States (USA)11-501972Private
Oberlin MarketingFort Wayne, Indiana, United States (USA)11-501987Corporate
Burkhart Insurance AgencyVincennes, Indiana, United States (USA)11-501988Private
Independent Insurance Brokerage, LLCCarmel, Indiana, United States (USA)51-2002020Private
Springer InsuranceSullivan, Indiana, United States (USA)11-501987Private
Torian InsuranceEvansville, Indiana, United States (USA)11-501923Private
Amstutz InsuranceFort Wayne, Indiana, United States (USA)11-501939Private
Advocate Financial Life & Health BrokerageFort Wayne, Indiana, United States (USA)11-502009Private


Want to Find More Medicare Supplement Insurance Companies?

If you want to find more companies that range from Medicare supplements to health insurance planning you can do so with Inven. This list was built with Inven and there are hundreds of companies like these globally.

With Inven you'll also get to know the company's:

  • Detailed Ownership: Who owns the company? Is it a public or private company? What is the ownership structure?
  • Contact data: Who are the founders and CEO's? What are their emails and phone numbers?
  • Financials: How do these companies perform financially? What are their revenues and profit margins?

...and a lot more!