Medicare supplement insurance companies in Ohio play a critical role in aiding seniors to cover healthcare expenses that Medicare does not fully pay for. This industry consists of independent agencies, corporate providers, and specialty firms, delivering a variety of plans including Medicare Advantage, Part D coverage, and Medigap policies. As healthcare costs rise and the aging population increases, these companies are evolving to offer more personalized services and resources to help clients make informed decisions. New technology is also making way for better access to plans, indicating a more customer-centric approach in the future.

The companies listed here are a mix of independent agencies and corporate providers, primarily located in Ohio cities like Cleveland, Akron, and Miamisburg. Founded between 1929 and 2019, these firms vary in size from small agencies with just a handful of employees to larger organizations employing thousands. They specialize mainly in Medicare-related services, providing products like Medicare Advantage plans and supplemental insurance that cater to community needs.

Read on to discover the top Medicare supplement insurance companies in Ohio.

Top 20 Medicare Supplement Insurance Companies in Ohio

1. Medical Mutual

• Website: medmutual.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Cleveland, Ohio, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1934
• Headcount: 1001-5000
• LinkedIn: medical-mutual

Medical Mutual of Ohio is a health insurance provider based in Cleveland, Ohio, with a history dating back to 1934. The company offers a variety of insurance plans, including medical, dental, vision, and notably, Medicare options. Medical Mutual serves individuals, families, and employers, focusing on helping them access necessary healthcare services and manage health-related expenses. Their Medicare offerings include both Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement Insurance plans, catering to the needs of seniors and those eligible for Medicare. The company emphasizes community health and operates across various locations in Ohio, showcasing a commitment to the well-being of its members. Medical Mutual also provides educational resources to help individuals navigate Medicare, further enhancing their role in the industry.

2. SSIP Insurance Partners

• Website: 1ssip.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Mansfield, Ohio, United States (USA)
• Founded year: 2009
• Headcount: 201-500
• LinkedIn: ssip-insurance-partners

SSIP Insurance Partners, based in Mansfield, Ohio, is a private insurance agency founded in 2009. The company specializes in a variety of insurance products, prominently featuring Medicare supplements and Medicare Advantage plans. SSIP aims to assist individuals, families, and businesses in securing their financial futures through comprehensive insurance solutions. Their offerings extend beyond health insurance to include life insurance and legacy planning services. The agency emphasizes education, providing resources to help clients navigate their options in Medicare and long-term care. With a workforce of approximately 44 employees, SSIP has established itself as a significant player in the insurance market, particularly in the senior demographic. Their focus on client education and support further enhances their relevance in the Medicare supplement sector.

3. Ohio Health Benefits LLC

• Website: ohiohealthbenefits.net
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Tallmadge, Ohio, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Latest funding: Other (Grant), March 2023
• Founded year: 2004
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: ohio-health-benefits-llc

Ohio Health Benefits LLC, based in Tallmadge, Ohio, is an independent insurance agency that has been operating since 2004. The company specializes in health insurance services, with a particular emphasis on Medicare options, including Medicare Advantage and Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plans. Ohio Health Benefits assists individuals and families in understanding their health insurance choices, providing tailored solutions to meet their unique needs. The agency prides itself on delivering exceptional customer service and personalized support, which is evident from the positive feedback received from clients. With a team of knowledgeable professionals, Ohio Health Benefits is dedicated to helping clients navigate the complexities of health insurance, ensuring they make informed decisions about their coverage. The company operates two offices in Ohio, allowing them to serve a broad client base across the state.

4. KAZ Company

• Website: medicareplansneo.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Independence, Ohio, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 2010
• Headcount: 51-200
• LinkedIn: kaz-company

KAZ Company, established in 2010, is an independent licensed insurance agency based in Independence, Ohio. Initially founded as a manufacturer’s representative for school supplies, the company pivoted to focus on Medicare health plans after the sale of its previous contracts. KAZ Company specializes in Medicare Supplement Plans, Medicare Advantage Plans, and Medicare Part D Prescription Plans, providing essential services to seniors navigating the complexities of Medicare. The agency prides itself on its educational approach, helping clients understand their options and make informed decisions about their healthcare coverage. KAZ Company operates primarily in Northeast Ohio and has developed a strong reputation for customer service, relying heavily on referrals for growth. The company is led by Kathy Hirko, who has a long-standing commitment to community service and client education. KAZ Company represents multiple Medicare insurance carriers, offering a range of products tailored to meet the needs of its clients.

5. Medicare Answers Now

• Website: medicareanswersnow.com
• Ownership type: Family Owned
• Headquarters: Cleveland, Ohio, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 2019
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: medicare-answers-now

Medicare Answers Now, based in Cleveland, Ohio, is a family-owned insurance agency that specializes in Medicare-related products and services. Founded in 2019, the company operates as a Field Marketing Organization (FMO) and has agents across more than 30 states. They provide a range of insurance solutions, including Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplements, and various health-related plans. The agency is dedicated to helping both consumers and insurance agents navigate the complexities of Medicare. They offer extensive training and resources to agents, including product training, business development coaching, and marketing tools. Additionally, Medicare Answers Now hosts significant industry events, such as the Ms. Medicare Conference and Medicare and Margaritas, which focus on networking and education for agents. Their commitment to professional development and support for agents highlights their active role in the Medicare insurance sector.

6. RetireMED

• Website: retiremediq.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Miamisburg, Ohio, United States (USA)
• Founded year: 2007
• Headcount: 51-200
• LinkedIn: retiremediq

RetireMED, founded in 2007 and based in Miamisburg, Ohio, operates under the legal name RetireMED IQ LLC. The company is dedicated to health insurance consulting, with a particular emphasis on Medicare services. They assist clients, especially those aged 65 and older, in understanding their Medicare options, eligibility, and enrollment processes. RetireMED's approach is client-centric, offering personalized support and resources to simplify the often complex Medicare landscape. They are licensed to sell health insurance plans in several states, including Ohio, Kentucky, Indiana, Pennsylvania, and Florida, and represent multiple organizations, providing access to a wide array of products. Their commitment to lifelong client support, offered at no cost, further underscores their role as advocates for individuals navigating Medicare.

7. Selman & Company

• Website: selmanco.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Cleveland, Ohio, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1980
• Headcount: 51-200
• LinkedIn: selman-%26-company

Selman & Company, based in Cleveland, Ohio, has been operational since 1980. This private insurance administrator focuses on providing comprehensive insurance administration services, particularly in the supplemental health insurance sector. They cater to a variety of clients, including associations, credit unions, banks, employers, and other insurance companies. Their services include billing, claims management, compliance, and customer support, all aimed at improving operational efficiency and reducing costs. Selman & Company markets its own insurance products, notably TRICARE and CHAMPVA supplements, which are relevant for individuals seeking additional coverage alongside their primary health plans. With a workforce of approximately 200 professionals, they maintain a strong presence in the insurance administration field, emphasizing customer service and strategic partnerships with recognized insurance carriers.

8. SummaCare

• Website: summacare.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Akron, Ohio, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1993
• Headcount: 201-500
• LinkedIn: summacare

SummaCare, founded in 1993 and based in Akron, Ohio, is a private health insurance provider that specializes in various health plans, including Medicare Advantage, individual, family, and employer health insurance. With a workforce of approximately 267 employees, the company is dedicated to serving the healthcare needs of consumers and businesses in Ohio. SummaCare emphasizes personalized care and offers a range of coverage options tailored to meet the specific health needs of its members. The company has established a solid reputation in the industry, evidenced by its high member retention rate and favorable ratings from regulatory bodies. SummaCare actively engages with the community, providing resources and support to enhance the health and well-being of its members. Their commitment to quality care and member satisfaction positions them as a relevant player in the Medicare insurance market.

9. Schwendeman Agency Inc

• Website: schwendeman.com
• Ownership type: Family Owned
• Headquarters: Saint Clairsville, Ohio, United States (USA)
• Founded year: 1929
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: schwendeman-agency-inc

Schwendeman Agency Inc. is a third-generation, family-owned insurance agency based in Marietta, Ohio. Founded in 1929, the agency has built a reputation for providing a wide array of insurance and financial services tailored to both individuals and businesses. Their offerings include employee benefits, personal insurance, business insurance, and notably, Medicare-related products such as Medicare supplements, Medicare Advantage plans, and Medicare Part D. The agency operates primarily in Ohio and West Virginia, emphasizing a commitment to customer service and personalized coverage solutions. Schwendeman Agency Inc. prides itself on its independent status, allowing it to offer various plans from multiple providers, ensuring clients receive the best options for their unique situations. Their long history and focus on Medicare products make them a relevant player in the insurance market.

10. RetireMed

• Website: retiremed.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Miamisburg, Ohio, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 2007
• Headcount: 51-200
• LinkedIn: retiremediq

RetireMed, operating under the legal name RetireMED IQ LLC, is a private health insurance advisory company based in Miamisburg, Ohio. Founded in 2007, the firm specializes in Medicare services, helping individuals understand their Medicare options, eligibility, and enrollment processes. With a dedicated team of approximately 113 employees, RetireMed has provided support to over 50,000 clients across Ohio, Kentucky, Indiana, Pennsylvania, and Florida. Their services are offered at no cost, emphasizing their commitment to lifelong client support. RetireMed collaborates with multiple insurance organizations, representing a wide array of products to ensure clients receive tailored advice and options that suit their unique healthcare needs. Their focus on education and advocacy in the Medicare space positions them as a significant resource for individuals approaching retirement or navigating Medicare complexities.

11. Stephens Matthews Marketing

• Website: stephens-matthews.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Beverly, Ohio, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1984
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: stephens-matthews-marketing

Stephens Matthews Marketing, Inc., based in Beverly, Ohio, has been a player in the insurance industry since its founding in 1984. This private agency specializes in a variety of health and life insurance products, with a particular emphasis on Medicare Supplement plans. They provide agents with essential training, resources, and tools to effectively market and sell Medicare and ACA products. Their commitment to agent support is evident through their professional field representatives who offer training both in-office and in group settings. The company operates in forty-nine states, showcasing its extensive reach within the insurance market. Their focus on agent service, product training, and lead generation tools positions them as a significant resource for agents in the Medicare space.

12. Paramount Health Care

• Website: paramounthealthcare.com
• Ownership type: Corporate
• Headquarters: Toledo, Ohio, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 97%, India 3%
• Latest funding: January 2024
• Founded year: 1988
• Headcount: 501-1000
• LinkedIn: paramount-health-care

Paramount Health Care, founded in 1988 and based in Toledo, Ohio, is a corporate health insurance provider with a workforce of approximately 556 employees. The company specializes in a variety of health plans, including Medicare, Marketplace, and Short-Term Insurance. Paramount is dedicated to assisting individuals, families, and employers in accessing affordable health coverage tailored to their specific needs. Their Medicare offerings include plans with $0 premium options and no copays for primary care visits and certain prescriptions, showcasing their focus on affordability and member support. Paramount Health Care is committed to promoting health and well-being through its insurance solutions, making it a significant player in the health insurance industry.

13. Ace Insurance Agency

• Website: aceinsuranceperry.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Sandusky, Ohio, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1984
• Headcount: 1-10
• LinkedIn: ace-insurance-agency-ohio

Ace Insurance Agency, established in 1984, is a small insurance agency located in Sandusky, Ohio. With a team of around 17 employees, the agency specializes in a wide array of insurance products, including personal, business, and Medicare insurance. They serve both individual consumers and businesses, focusing on tailored insurance solutions to meet the unique needs of their clients. The agency has a particular emphasis on Medicare, offering Medicare Advantage plans, Medicare Supplement plans, and prescription savings options. Their commitment to the local community is evident in their mission to provide high-quality service and support to clients along the shores of Lake Erie. Ace Insurance Agency is licensed to operate in Ohio and Michigan, further solidifying its regional presence in the insurance market.

14. Berson-Sokol Agency, Inc.

• Website: berson-sokol.com
• Ownership type: Family Owned
• Headquarters: Cleveland, Ohio, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1973
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: berson-sokol-agency-inc.

Berson-Sokol Agency, Inc. is an insurance agency based in Cleveland, Ohio, founded in 1973. This family-owned business has built a reputation for providing comprehensive support to insurance agents and advisors, particularly in the areas of life insurance, annuities, senior health care, and long-term care services. With a dedicated focus on senior health care, Berson-Sokol offers products that include Medicare Advantage, Medicare Supplement plans, and ancillary services such as dental and vision coverage. The agency prides itself on its strong relationships with over 40 major carriers, ensuring that agents have access to a wide array of products tailored to meet the unique needs of their clients. Berson-Sokol has placed more than $30 billion in life insurance in-force and continues to adapt to the evolving insurance landscape, emphasizing technology and personalized service to enhance agent performance and client satisfaction.

15. Leugers Insurance Agency, Inc

• Website: leugersins.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Maria Stein, Ohio, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1914
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: leugers-insurance-agency-inc

Leugers Insurance Agency, Inc., based in Maria Stein, Ohio, has been serving clients since 1914. This independent insurance agency provides a wide array of insurance products and financial services tailored to both individuals and businesses. Their offerings include personal, agricultural, business, life, Medicare, and health insurance, alongside financial planning and investment management services. The agency prides itself on its customer-centric approach, emphasizing the importance of understanding client needs and delivering personalized solutions. With a dedicated team of professionals, Leugers Insurance Agency aims to simplify the insurance process for its clients, particularly in navigating the complexities of Medicare and its various plans. Their commitment to service is reflected in their client testimonials, which highlight their attentiveness and support. The agency operates multiple offices across Ohio, enhancing their accessibility to clients in the region.

16. TLC Insurance Group & Wealth

• Website: tlcinsurancegroup.com
• Ownership type: Corporate
• Headquarters: Warren, Ohio, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Latest funding: September 2020
• Founded year: 1997
• Headcount: 51-200
• LinkedIn: tlc-insurance-group

TLC Insurance Group & Wealth, founded in 1997 and based in Warren, Ohio, operates as an insurance brokerage and wealth management firm. The company specializes in Medicare plans, property and casualty insurance, and retirement planning. With a workforce of approximately 86 employees, TLC Insurance Group is dedicated to serving individuals, retirees, and businesses by providing customized insurance and financial solutions. Their Medicare offerings include both individual and group plans, catering to the unique needs of retirees and their families. The firm prides itself on its commitment to customer service, ensuring that clients receive year-round support through its National Concierge Service Department. TLC Insurance Group has established a significant presence in the Medicare market, representing 46 organizations and offering a variety of products tailored to the Medicare-eligible population.

17. Homestead Insurance Agency

• Website: homesteadins.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Brunswick, Ohio, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1934
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: homestead-insurance-agency

Homestead Insurance Agency, based in Brunswick, Ohio, has been serving the insurance needs of individuals and businesses since its founding in 1934. With a team of 15 employees, the agency prides itself on building long-term relationships with clients in the Medina and Brunswick communities. They offer a wide array of insurance products, including homeowners, auto, business, life, health, and Medicare insurance. Their approach is centered on understanding the unique needs of each client and providing tailored insurance solutions. The agency works with a selection of reputable insurance companies to ensure that clients receive comprehensive coverage at competitive prices. Over the years, Homestead Insurance has established a reputation for excellent customer service, as evidenced by numerous positive testimonials from satisfied clients. Their commitment to the community is reflected in their active participation in local organizations and charitable initiatives, further solidifying their role as a trusted insurance provider in the region.

18. Paige & Byrnes Insurance

• Website: paigebyrnes.com
• Ownership type: Family Owned
• Headquarters: Warren, Ohio, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1921
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: paige-%26-byrnes-insurance

Paige & Byrnes Insurance is a family-owned independent insurance agency based in Warren, Ohio, with a history dating back to 1921. The agency specializes in a wide range of insurance solutions, including personal, business, and employee benefits. They serve both individual consumers and businesses throughout Northeast Ohio, focusing on providing tailored insurance products that manage risks and protect assets. Their offerings include Medicare Supplement Insurance, which is a critical component for many seniors seeking to enhance their healthcare coverage. The agency prides itself on exceptional customer service and has built strong relationships within the community, which is reflected in their client testimonials. With a dedicated team that includes specialists in personal lines, commercial lines, and life and health insurance, Paige & Byrnes Insurance aims to meet the unique needs of their clients while navigating the complexities of insurance.

19. Grant Insurance

• Website: grantinsurance.com
• Ownership type: Private
• Headquarters: Defiance, Ohio, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1936
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: grant-insurance-agency

Grant Insurance, based in Defiance, Ohio, has been providing insurance solutions since 1936. With a team of 23 employees, the agency specializes in a wide array of insurance products, including personal, business, farm, life, and notably, Medicare insurance. Their commitment to customer service is evident in their tailored offerings designed to meet the unique needs of both individuals and businesses. Grant Insurance actively participates in the Medicare market, offering Medicare Supplements, Medicare Advantage Plans, and Part D Plans. They represent five organizations that provide 42 products in their area, showcasing their involvement in the Medicare sector. The agency's focus on delivering peace of mind through comprehensive insurance solutions positions them as a relevant player in the Medicare supplement insurance space.

20. Advanced Insurance Designs, Inc.

• Website: aidiconnect.com
• Ownership type: Family Owned
• Headquarters: Akron, Ohio, United States (USA)
• Employee distribution: United States (USA) 100%
• Founded year: 1977
• Headcount: 11-50
• LinkedIn: advanced-insurance-designs-inc

Advanced Insurance Designs, Inc. is an insurance agency based in Akron, Ohio, with a history dating back to 1977. As a family-owned business, they pride themselves on delivering personalized service and building trusted relationships with their clients. The agency specializes in a wide range of insurance products, including health, business, personal, and notably, Medicare insurance. Their Medicare offerings include General Medicare, Medicare Advantage, and Medicare Part D, along with additional services like dental, vision, and hearing coverage. The company operates with a team of knowledgeable insurance professionals who are dedicated to understanding client needs and providing tailored insurance solutions. They serve individuals, families, and businesses throughout Ohio, emphasizing a consultative approach to insurance. Advanced Insurance Designs, Inc. has not reported any funding, indicating a stable, self-sustaining operation.

Medicare Supplement Insurance Insights: Key Companies in Ohio

Want to Find More Medicare Supplement Insurance Companies?

With Inven you'll also get to know the company's:

• Detailed Ownership: Who owns the company? Is it a public or private company? What is the ownership structure?
• Contact data: Who are the founders and CEO's? What are their emails and phone numbers?
• Financials: How do these companies perform financially? What are their revenues and profit margins?

...and a lot more!